Author’s Note: Given the fast-paced nature of tariffs developments, please note that this article was published on April 11th, 2025.
In April 2025, sweeping changes in U.S. trade policy set the stage for a major transformation in the Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG) industry. The new tariff regime that was launched on April 2nd with variable rates based on the US trade deficits was dramatically altered on April 9th, when tariffs delayed by 90 days and were slashed to 10% for imports into the US, with the notable exception of China. At the time of writing, tit-for-tat tariffs had risen to 145% for imports of Chinese goods and 125% for Chinese imports of US goods. (NYTimes source) These measures aim to boost domestic production and protect U.S. industries. As a result, companies across the CPG sector are rapidly rethinking their sourcing, pricing, and shelf strategies.
Source NYTimes: China Raises Tariffs on U.S. Imports to 125%, Calling Trump’s Policies a ‘Joke’ link
The new tariffs force companies to carefully reconsider where and how they source their components and ingredients. Firms with robust domestic supply chains have a clear advantage, as they largely bypass the extra costs that burden import-dependent competitors leading to a competitive margin advantage. Conversely, companies that rely heavily on global suppliers must now absorb higher costs or pass them on to consumers, which can put significant pressure on their profit margins and sales volume.
With these trade policy changes, traditional pricing models and retail shelf strategies no longer guarantee competitive strength. Firms now face the dual challenge of adjusting prices without alienating customers while managing increased material costs. Moreover, as suppliers adjust their ingredient sources in response to tariff pressures, variations in product quality can drive dissatisfaction from loyal customers—prompting the need for a nimble approach to both production and marketing. Finally, as prices and recession fears rise, CPG consumers are more likely to trade down to more affordable brands, including switching to private label (store brand) options.
In today's rapidly evolving trade climate, hesitation is not an option. Businesses must accelerate their decision-making in product development, strategic repositioning, and overall competitive tactics. Uncertainty about what tariff rate will hit when for which country adds layers of complexity, requiring continuous evaluation of how shifts in the global supply chain impact every element of production—from raw material costs to product innovation cycles.
To navigate these uncertainties, companies must lean heavily on data - specifically, real-time data. Integrating quantitative insights from diverse sources—including price fluctuations and evolving consumer purchase behaviors—enables firms to assess the profitability of modifying production lines, scaling back commodity purchases, or making investments. Robust and regular data analysis is essential to adapt strategies swiftly and maintain a competitive edge.
Periods of rapid regulatory change and market uncertainty underscore the need to make tracking consumer sentiment a critical component of a successful strategy. When modifications in supplier arrangements or ingredient sources occur, early signals from real-time feedback—collected via sources like product reviews and customer care communications—can alert companies to shifts in consumer expectations long before problems escalate and competitors take advantage of the crisis.
Advanced sentiment monitoring tools should provide granular data that breaks down consumer sentiment by individual retailer and geographic region. This will enable companies to assess how local market conditions are evolving, going beyond sales data to pinpoint where demand is strong or where supply chain hiccups are causing delays. For instance, when monitoring sentiment data, brands might observe that their products are receiving high praise at one retailer for quick stock replenishment in a specific region, while another is flagged for repeated customer complaints about delayed deliveries. Such precise insights allow for targeted operational adjustments and marketing campaigns, directly addressing local issues and capitalizing on regional strengths.
To stay ahead, CPG brands need more than internal agility—they must understand how competitors are adapting to the same challenges. Tracking local shifts in stock rollouts, pricing, and promotions offers valuable context for refining your own strategy.
It’s especially useful to keep an eye on competitors with domestic supply chains. While they may gain advantages in cost or speed, sentiment and operations data can uncover unmet consumer expectations—such as flavor inconsistencies, assembly issues, or packaging missteps. These insights can guide more thoughtful positioning and campaigns that authentically spotlight your brand’s strengths.
One often-overlooked benefit of modern sentiment monitoring platforms is their ability to surface insights around price-to-value perceptions across the competitive landscape. By evaluating what consumers are saying about pricing and value—not just for your brand, but for others in your category—you can identify whether shoppers perceive your product as worth the cost, or whether they’re considering cheaper alternatives. These insights are especially valuable when contemplating price changes. They can inform whether a pricing shift could be absorbed without alienating loyal customers, or whether perceived value is fragile and risks prompting trade-down behavior.
Below is a sample of how stark sentiment variations can be for price/value across a category (shown from a scale of -1 to 1.)
Another important element is the systematic tracking of customer care interactions. Feedback from customer service channels often highlights pain points related to product quality, pricing issues, or supply chain disruptions. By carefully analyzing this data, companies can identify problems early, address emerging issues quickly, and maintain a strong connection with their consumer base. This proactive approach not only helps in mitigating negative sentiment but also reinforces consumer trust in the brand.
The new global and domestic tariffs are catalyzing significant changes in the CPG industry. Companies are now compelled to reconfigure their supply chains, reassess pricing strategies, retool their product portfolios, and reimagine retail shelf placements. In such a volatile trade environment, the ability to monitor real‑time consumer sentiment—including location-specific feedback, competitive insights, and detailed customer care data—is key to swiftly adjusting tactics and optimizing product positioning.
Investing in robust, real‑time sentiment monitoring systems can provide the essential insights needed to stay ahead of market shifts and meet evolving consumer demands. As the industry adapts to these new dynamics, a focus on agile, data‑driven strategies will be critical for success.
Source NYTimes: China Raises Tariffs on U.S. Imports to 125%, Calling Trump’s Policies a ‘Joke’ link
.svg)
